31.1.08

Privacy for sale: Angelina Jolie to confirm pregnancy to the highest bidder



While celebrities and the courts argue over the parameters of the human right to privacy and protecting celebrities and others from unwanted media intrusion and speculation, their quest to find a legal and moral centreground is undermined by the commercial forces at play.

Reports suggest that Angelina Jolie is offering an exclusive to confirm her pregnancy to the highest bidder. While the monies will go to some well deserving charity the concept and acceptance of it set a tricky precedent. To the extent that the money raised by this publicity stunt may well benefit a good cause it also puts a price on the sale of this confirmation and/or 'exclusive' and sends out the message that - whether for charity or not - such private information is for sale to the highest bidder.

This poses a legal and regulatory dilemma insofar as the legal system is - through the Human Rights Act and European Convention - charged to protect the right to private information. So if celebrities are allowed to sell their private information to the highest bidder why should the law step in and prevent this or similar information being published when a celebrity decides they don't want this information to be published or that the price they are being offered isn't right.

There is a need to separate the human rights based protection of privacy from the commercial regulation of private information as a tradable commodity. As the law stands intellectual property and associated licensing laws allow for the commercial exploitation while human rights laws and self regulatory codes deal with non-commercially regulated intrusion. This separation may seem workable at one level but there have been enough cases to prove it is not.

A prime example is the case of Douglas v Hello where Catherine Zeta-Jones and Michael Douglas had entered into an exclsuive licensing deal that allowed OK! magazine to take and publish photographs of their wedding. Rival Hello magazine managed to obtain some sneakily taken snapshots from the wedding an printed them ahead of OK!'s official wedding pictures release. The protracted and ensuing legal action saw OK! magazine use the pretext of the Douglases privacy to sue rival Hello magazine for the revenues it lost as a result of Hello's spoiler. This is perverse and so too is the ruling that ultimately acknowledged some such right. It is illogical and arguably an abuse of process to use human rights related laws to protect privacy rights that one has already sold for commercial gain.

To the extent that one seeks to commercialise one's private life and information, one compromises the human right to privacy in that information. The very fact that a right is for sale means that the holder of the right has ascribed a value to it and anyone paying the price can, by implication, override the privacy in it. So where a right has been so commercialised, then any use of the private material that falls outside the terms of the commercial deal is surely a contractual issue relating to a breach in commercial exploitation or licensing rights as opposed to a human rights issue.

There remains much confusion between the two and the willingness of Angelina Jolie to commercialise her private news may serve a charity but does little to help clarify an already confused law. If there were new legislation that distinguished between privacy in a human rights sense and as a commercial commodity then that would serve to clarify an unsatisfactory interpretation and application of the laws that are currently being mixed and matched to address the various interpretations of what constitute privacy issues.

30.1.08

PCC Chairman calls for revamp of 'pretty weird' regulation



PCC Chairman Sir Christopher Meyer has honestly laid out the challenge that faces media regulation. Appearing before the House of Lords Communications Committee he acknowledged that the current system of regulation - knitting together the PCC that covers print and online press, Ofcom for broadcast and the ASA for advertising was a mix of regimes that would benefit from rationalisation and reorganisation.

Meyer's comments are welcome in that they point to an acceptance of what needs to be done with media regulation in the UK and the need for an inclusive and cohesive approach between rules for print, broadcast, online and adverts. A review and shake up of the regulatory regime would be both welcome and necessary. It would be preferable to reorganise the self-regulatory landscape along lines that acknowledge developments in law, regulation and technology than to keep manipulating the suite of out-of-date laws that surround it. If regulation took the funamental principles of the European Human Rights Convention as its backdrop and then worked outwards from that it could take regulation where it needs to be and create some clarity and workable rules for the media. This would be preferable to any legislative measures in areas such as privacy which successive parliaments have steered clear from and would be difficult to frame along the flexible lines that are required.

More HERE

Ryanair scores PR hit with ad outrage



What may have been intended to be a cheeky ad has made its way into the headlines in what - giving the Ryanair PR team the benefit of the doubt - is some clever manipulation of the situation. The ASA (Advertising Standards Authority) received 13 complaints that the advert depicting an adult in schoolgirl's clothing was sexually suggestive in an inappropriate manner and - most likely for being held to account if they ran the ad rather than agreeing with the ASA or wanting to turn away the revenue - several papers refused to run it.
The ASA ruled that the advert breached s2.2 Social Responsibility and s5.1 Decency parts of the non broadcast advertising code

While the intent of the advert may not have been to be suggestive in an inappropriate manner - though the company can't realistically argue that the thought wouldn't have crossed its collective mind - the handling of the fallout has secured Ryanair primetime TV spots and front pages. Had they accepted the ASA's findings, withdrawn the ad and apologised then there might have been some comment but the fact that they openly taunted the ASA with their response that accused the ASA of being a "bunch of unelected self-appointed dimwits are clearly incapable of fairly and impartially ruling on advertising" ensured the story got picked up as news and has now hit the headlines.

While all of this may not have been deliberate the exposure Ryanair has got is priceless - if one were to go a step further one could even say that the decision to run the ad was linked more to the Britney association than to the inappropriate sexualisation of schoolgirls - given Britney's media exposure that association would also ensure the ad leveraged from the linkage.

A vox pop on one of this evening's news programmes summed up the reality of the situation - "what has it got to do with aeroplanes"

More HERE

Should critics be subject to defamation law?



The Court of Appeal in Belfast has retired to consider its decision on whether to allow an appeal by the Irish News against a £25,000 libel award over a restaurant review.





As previously reported on Mediabeak, last year a jury decided that the paper should pay out for publishing a review of Goodfellas Restaurant in Belfast that was critical of the eating experience and awarded a low star rating. What may seemingly be a regular libel action harbours significant issues over whether subjective reviews should be subject to libel law and, if they are, what that means for the competing right of free speech.

More from MediaGuardian

29.1.08

Doors closed on open justice - Court of Appeal upholds gag on murder trial

The Court of Appeal has this week upheld an order that allows a significant proportion of a defendant's testimony to be held in secret. As previously reported on Mediabeak the case concerns the murder of a wealthy author, Allan Chappelow who died from head injuries following a burglary at his Hampstead home in June 2006.

The defendant and the media had petitioned the Home Secretary to allow the case to be heard in open court rather than behind closed doors. The state had successfully secured a gag over proceedings on the basis of national security. At the heart of the case lies the, as yet, and in light of the gag probably never, substantiated allegaton that the death of Chappelow may have had some connection with the securtiy services. The Court of Appeal has upheld the original order granted by Mr Justice Ouseley - insofar as the judge had 'correctly applied the relevant law to the facts before him' - which is legalspeak for the judge followed the letter of the law as far as it could be construed towards the state - i.e. played it safe.

This decision is a shame given that it was not just the media but the defendant who was keen to have full public exposure and discussion of the truth. It is another example of how 'national security' can be used to trump the truth even in the wake of the Human Rights Act. To add to gravitas, Mr Justice Ouseley's original order also cautioned journslists that speculation about the case could amont to contempt - so no pressure there! - Mediabeak would like to stress that this report does not speculate in any way about the case or its merits, it merely questions the right to obtain more information to prevent such speculation.

More HERE

Multimedia trial coverage - local rape reaches international readers

Exeter based Express and Echo has been running a pilot programme that put its multimedia capabilities to the test through its reporting of a brutal rape that had left a profound affect on the city. Mediabeak reported on the pilot scheme that started earlier this month as the trial got underway at Exeter Crown Court of a polish man accused of raping a 48 year old mother in the centre of town. Showing little remorse, Tomczak had carried out what police descibed as one of the most horrendous crimes they had been asked to investigate. Whether the coverage achieved its aim of brining the trial closer to its readers is up for debate. It appears that while the local press provided welcome reportage, police were displeased by the Polish media's interpretation of the judicial process.

More HERE

28.1.08

J'Accuse - Alastair Campbell attacks media over "culture of negativity"



The grand political puppetmaster of spin Alastair Campbell has this evening attacked the media over its "culture of negativity" and significant fall in standards. Delivering the Hugh Cudlipp lecture at the London College of Communication, Campbell used the platform to attack the sales and headline driven focus of the media, drawing on the ongoing McCann repoting as an example of what's wrong with how our press approach their subject matter.

More on this evening's talk from MediaGuardian


Mediabeak will be delivering a talk on the McCanns and the media - analysing the media's treatment(s) and approach to the story as it unfolded and how it still achieves front pages. (See further posting for details - talks will be held in February and March in London and Bournemouth)

Ofcom: Latest complaints bulletin - user generated content under fire



Ofcom's latest Complaints Bulletin, published today, finds Sumo TV in breach over inappropriate user generated content and sees MTV's Music Factory held to account over its automated competitions.

The issue of user generated content is particularly of note as the proliferation of UGC and 'social networking' sites such as You Tube or Facebook have led to cases that are setting the scene for what will be testing times for regulators, broadcasters and ISPs as they grapple with how to encourage interactivity while still policing standards in respect of the content that ends up being published and uploaded or downloaded.

Ofcom reminded broadcasters about its concerns over UGC:

"User-generated content
Ofcom is concerned that some channels broadcasting considerable amounts of user-generated content may attempt to place too much responsibility for ensuring compliance with the Code with the individual user, and not perform sufficient checks themselves. Responsibility for compliance with the Code always remains with the broadcaster. Proportionate but robust pre-broadcast checks may impose extra costs on the broadcaster, and limit the amount of user-generated content it can air. However, it is clearly important to ensure that people aged under eighteen are appropriately protected, and that individuals appearing in items are not unjustly or unfairly treated or have their privacy unwarrantably infringed. Ofcom therefore reminds licensees who broadcast user-generated content of their responsibilities to ensure full compliance with the Code, and in particular with the sections in respect of Protecting the Under Eighteens, Harm and Offence, and the Fairness and Privacy.

Broadcasters need to be aware that simply because material is available on the web, this does not mean that it is automatically suitable for broadcast on a licensed service which has to comply with the standards as set out in the Communications Act"

More analysis from Mediabeak to follow...

22.1.08

Privacy claim: Liz Hurley and Hugh Grant sue over holiday snaps



Liz Hurley, her husband Arun Nayar and Hugh Grant are heading to the High Court where they are suing picture agencies Big Pictures and Eliot Press for privacy invasion. Both agencies are no stranger to legal action - Ewan McGregor having secured a payout against Eliot Press over photographs taken while he was holidaying with his family in Mauritius while Big Pictures have been in the frame for several actions such as the famous David Beckham 'Golden Balls' picture.

The three friends are complaining about pictures that were taken while they shared a holiday in the Maldives last October. The rules and laws of privacy have seen much confusion in the past and inconsistency in the approach taken by the courts. Much of this centred around the notion that one only had - in line with the law and self-regulatory codes - a 'reasonable expectation of privacy' if one were somewhere truly private, in the sense it was not accessible (or meant to be) to the outside world. What recent rulings have clarified is that the human right to privacy as conferred by article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights and given effect to in the UK via the 1998 Human Rights Act, is portable. In other words, as a human right it attaches to the person rather than the location - if the activity, albeit in an ostensibly 'public' place, is of a private nature (and in absence of any competing right of the public or the press to expose wrongdoing or the invasion being justified by the deception it exposed) then the human right to privacy stands and the state directly and the press indirectly have a duty to respect and uphold that privacy.

This changing landscape and clearer delineation of privacy law has come via the European Court ruling in the case of Hanover v. Germany and was confirmed in the self-regulatory context through the PCC's adjudication over a complaint by Elle McPherson in January last year.

What is interesting and differentiates this case is that, according to reports, Hurley, her husband and former lover, are seeking restitution in the form of a share of the profits creamed off by the picture agencies rather than a straight and fixed damages award.

This makes sense. The pictures are out there and can't be retracted (though an injunction can secure they cannot be reissued) so why not profit from their sale? If the profits from sale are likely to be greater than a damages award then it makes sense to ask the court to order that option.

Another KEY reason for doing this that supports a TREND Mediabeak predicts is that by doing so the legal action changes - what the courts are being asked is to recognise the intellectual property worth of the image as a commodity (use of image obtained without permission and in an unlicensed manner) and/or data protection angle (one's image as captured on camera as being part of one's personal information). What this means is that what Hurley and others in her position would claim is that their picture has been used without permission for the commerical benefit of a third party and as such that third party has to compensate them for the loss of control over their image rights and - should they wish - being able to sell that picture themselves. This makes for a clearer cut commercial and hopefully also legal argument - one is no longer trying to balance the right of the celebrity to privacy against the media's (self) appointed right to report but is taken into a more easily quantifiable commercial context of the financial exploitation potential of their image.

What Hurley and similar legal actions will be saying is OK, I'm not hung up about my human right to privacy and want to get drawn into a ridiculous court battle over when one's actions or where one is might attract that human right BUT what I am saying is that you have used a picture of me and are trading off my celebrity or picture selling status to exploit my image without my permission - that's basically ripping me off and you will need to compensate me for it. This approach is making increasing sense and is more likely to find resonance in the courtrooms that are more used to ajudicating over property rights than they are over persona related rights.

So there is hope, not just for Hurley and their lawyer's success but for the emergence of a clearer legal landscape in relation to privacy and image rights and how the English and other legal systems deal with this historically thorny issue.

21.1.08

Who's suing who this week - Kate Moss, Suzanne Shaw and 'An East Grinstead Woman'

There's no let up in those upset by what they've seen or read - and while libel lawyers may have maligned a fairly static market over the past 18 months, there does seem to be a sustaining flow of cases coming through to play with. This weeks offerings are - according to unverified reports - being led by 34 year-old, 34 hour (or not, depending on which paper, mag or site you read) party girl Kate Moss. News of the World cited a 'source' as reason to believe she had rounded off her birthday celebrations with an orgy at the Dorchester hotel in London. Other papers had said she'd actually left her party and couldn't go the distance (whatever that was) so there are plenty of conflicting 'stories'.

However her partying ended it was not, apparently, in the form of an orgy and Mossy has apparently instructed Harbottle and Lewis to defend her honour.

Reports of legal action have so far been carried by purveyors of such news in the form of:
Entertainmentwise and Heatworld

Next up we have Suzanne Shaw - the former Hear'Say member who has made a return via the reality tv world that is Dancing on Ice - she's going to sue anyone who publishes details of or markets sex tapes that she has falsely been linked to. The tapes have been around since 2001 but have now regained their currency through her appearance on ice antics. If its not her in the pictures then the real person has missed an opportunity to sell their story to the tabloids - "It was me in those pics" - meanwhile anyone trying to make money out of Shaw-lookalike sex should know that she's on their case. That case could however be a difficult one to police or prove if clips that have previously done the rounds resurface on the likes of YouTube with not discernible originator.

And finally we turn to what the Press Gazette reported on as "a legal battle for libel damages brought by an East Grinstead woman". The woman in question goes under the name of Amber Daunt and she's particularly displeased with 'Take a Break' (Kitkat being optional) magazine over an article she claims was defamatory and in respect of which she is seeking £200,000 damages. There aren't too many details on what caused her such upset but in tabloid parlance 'its got Amber seeing red'.

Four jailed for defaming student on Facebook



In what could be one of the first cases of its kind, four people have been jailed for defamation following a complaint by a female student that they had posted pictures taken without her permission as well as offensive and sexually defamatory comments that had appeared on the social networking site. As Mediabeak reported recently, bulletin board and chatroom contributors need to beware as what they may consider to be personal postings are very much public publications and as such subject to defamation law.

This case is (as far as Mediabeak can ascertain) the first where Facebook users have been in the frame for posting objectionable content - there have been cases where Facebook comment has been cited in evidence to prove criminal intent but not in relation to defamation. The current case took place in Lebanon and was proscecuted under criminal law rather than via press related laws. There is some controversy surrounding the detention of the four accused. After a week in jail they were released but have still to stand trial.

Another interesting point is that the perpetrators found out that they were being reported to the authorities and deleted all the comments but the victim had saved copies and these were admitted as proof. From a legal point of view removing a posting will prevent it from further being capable of being defamatory but it will not make the fact it was online and capable of being read by infinite amounts of people go away - it was still published and the fact and effect of that publication will be admissable as evidence.

There are differences across jurisdictions in how defamation is litigated - in this case the criminal option was used while in the UK one would follow a civil action. Facebook itself is not liable as has a disclaimer in its terms of use and cannot be expected to police all of the content it facilitates worldwide. If however it had been made aware of misuse of its service and offensive material and done nothing to address or prevent this then arguably it could attract liability.

What is clear is that what may be seen as 'social networking' is equally 'social comment' and where such comment is defamatory it will be subject to the same laws as any other form of publication.

More in this case from Menassat - an interesting Lebanese site Mediabeak has been reading

Hellish kitchen - restaurant libel case puts press freedom to the test



As previously commented upon by Mediabeak, The Irish News is heading to the Court of Appeal in Belfast this week to contest a £25,000 libel ruling it was hit with last year over a review its restuarant critic Caroline Workman had provided back in 2000. Reviews are normally seen a subjective criticism and part of the wider review landscape so last year's ruling that saw the Irish News fined for carrying a critical review of Goodfellas came as an unwelcome surprise for it and the wider media who understandably regard this as a damning blow to free speech. There is an established assumption that reviews are subjective and in publishing them, newspapers are presenting rather than condoning the views expressed in them. The question that arises is to what extent can such fee speech be immune from sanction?

Defamation is predicated upon the publication of statements that damage the reputation of an individual, organisation or business, in this case a restaurant. One defence is to prove that the statement is true.

This poses problems when it comes to reviews, be they of restaurants, or anything else for that matter. The whole nature of a review is subjective, presenting the opinion of the reviewer, and hence there is no true of false.

So if the Belfast Appeal Court fails to allow the appeal then this will be bad news for the press and the ability to offer 'critique' over life's gastronomic, literary and artiscitc offerings. While comment shouldn't be allowed to irresponsibly ruin commercial enterprise of a gastronomic or artistic nature, it does have a place to assess the quality of these enterprises in the context of the public they serve. So if you can't stand the heat get out of the proverbial kitchen - one doesn't see the likes of Gordon Ramsay get all precious over a review - instead he growls in his various kitchens and ensures the product is right and the review will (in most cases) take care of itself.

Check back with Mediabeak for the latest from the appeal hearing after it gets underway on Wednesday.

20.1.08

McCann watch: Express stoops to new lows to secure headline

Having moved on from Diana conspiracy theories the Express has now turned its attentions to the McCanns. Its editorials have offered nothing of 'newsbreaking' value to the Diana coverage and have provided nothing beyond recycled stories in relation to the McCanns. This Sunday's offering, suggesting the 'agony' of Madeleine had led to a McCann 'split' was as gratuitous and cheap as it was substanceless - as noted by Greenslade.

It is perhaps surprising that the McCann's have managed to remain focused and togther INSPITE of the media coverage that has been driven by speculation rather than substance. Greenslade's rebuke is totally justified and hopefully the PCC will be engaged to deal with this cheap excuse of a headline. Having spotted the headline, Mediabeak did decide to read the story but all it confirmed was that the Express is as far away from a real investigative scoop or news story as it has been for quite some time. So the money one might have wasted on buying a print copy may aid its struggling circulation but will not enhance its reputation.

What the McCann coverage and even the repositioning of our heroic BA flight Captain and First Officer reporting tell us is that the tabloids are experts at packaging and selling stories but the stories of today are no match for the proper news that used to be delivered by the press of yesteryear.

18.1.08

Sienna Miller wins further privacy ruling


As Mediabeak reported in December. Sienna Miller won a privacy payout from The Sun and News of the World which had featured illicit photographs taken from the set of the movie 'Hippie Hippie Shake'.

As Mediabeak pointed out last month. Miller was not going to walk away from the legal action until she had also silenced the photographer who had sold the offending pictures to the press. The picture agency, Xposure and publishers News Group Newspapers have already been hit with a £37,500 + legal costs payout but this week it was photographer Warren Richardson's turn to face the music and payout for this privacy invasion. High Court Judge Mr Justice Eady granted an injunction preventing further disseminating the offending pictures and ordered that sneaky snapper Richardson would have to pay the costs of the litigation as well as damages to be assessed at a later date - Richardson can only hope that his fee from 'Xposure' was worth it.

More HERE

17.1.08

Mediabeak on the rise in PCC complaints - online access fuels rise in PCC complaints




As Mediabeak reported yesterday, the number of complaints handled by the PCC in the last year has continued to rise but what lies behind the increase? Are we faced with a less responsible press or a more vigilant audience and accesible complaints procedures?

While complaints about the press have increased, this is as much due to the accessibility and transparency of the process as it is about the misbehaviour of the press. The PCC is tasked with policing the online environment and has now also got jurisdiction over audio-visual online content (via a remit extension granted early in 2007 - that saw its first case in August last year)

With complaints reaching record levels Mediabeak was interested to ascertain the split between online and print generated complaints. The PCC has swiftly and kindly provided the following information:

55% of complainants provided online versions of articles, compared to 45% who provided the hard copies.

This statistic is interesting not in relation to the basis for the complaint but for what it tells us about where the complained of story originates from. Consistent with a trend in online news readership being greater than print, more complainants link to online articles as the originating source of their complaint than hard copy print versions. This can be further explained by two factors: first, that more people access, source, browse or stumble upon news via the internet and second, once posted, the majority of stories remain available directly or via archive online. Whereas in the past someone may have passed on an outrageous story they had read in a paper as 'hearsay' such hearsay is now replaced by an online search that allows an infinitely wide audience of people to directly access and see that which may have offended the originating person.

So while some may say its a bad thing complaints continue to rise, the other side of the argument is that such increase is good in that is shows that the press and readership are increasing interaction and feedback through a regulatory system that works. The PCC and its effectiveness may have been maligned in the past by individuals who thought they did not have sufficient protection or compensation from the press but as a self-regulatory body it is becoming more visible, relevant and effecitve. So an increase in complaints is actually a good thing in that is shows that self-regulation can work.