11.1.08

Tom Cruise wedding picture extortionist escapes jail sentence




A computer repairer who had tried to extort over £1m dollars from Tom Cruise for stolen wedding pictures has been sentenced to two years probation and fined $3000. A photographer had entrusted Marc Gittleman with the repair of his computer but when Gittleman discovered over 7,000 pictures of Cruise’s 2006 wedding to Katie Holmes on its hard drive he decided it was a good idea to copy and use them to blackmail Cruise.

He enlisted the help of a serial celebrity picture peddler (who has since committed suicide) and tried to get Cruise to hand over $1.3m. Having shown suitable contrition for his shame, the judge at the District Court in Los Angeles took pity on him and agreed with lawyers from both parties that it was not necessary to send him to jail.

More HERE

10.1.08

Golf Channel suspends presenter over Tiger Woods lynching jibe



US cable tv station the Golf Channel has suspended its anchor Kelly Tilghman for an offensive choice of phrase in discussing Tiger Woods performance at the second round of the PGA Tour season. In what she conceded was a poor choice of words she commented to Nick Faldo that if other players wanted to challenge Woods they'd have to "lynch him in a back alley".

She claimed this was all in jest and that she's known Tiger for over a decade and this was not meant to be offensive but her bosses at the channel took appropriate action making it clear that alluding to the lynch mob actions of the past was not acceptable, least not on air. Her comments were accepted as jest by Woods but civil rights activist the Reverend Al Sharpton has got on the case and is demanding Tilghman's scalp (metaphorically of course!)

The media are making mileage out of this - reports from Reuters
CNN
ABC News

Express and Echo pilots blanket multimedia coverage on rape trial



The Express and Echo newspaper is planning to exploit its full multimedia capabilities to bring readers rolling coverage of a rape trial. The trial which starts next week is expected to last three weeks and has attracted large local interest following the brutal rape of a 48 year old mother.

In addition to several pages in the newspaper, readers can logon to the paper's website where there will be hourly updates and video reports from outside the court. Readers will also be treated to text alerts so they can be kept up to date with the trial while on the move.

This is the closest to streaming live video footage from inside the court that multimedia news can deliver but will put the paper's editorial compliance to the test as there are strict reporting restrictions - in relation to rape cases in particular and contempt rules in general - that will need to be observed.

Full details from HoldTheFrontPage

France to scrap ads on state TV

French President Nicolas Sarkozy has this week announced plans to scrap adverts on state funded broadcasters. The move, aimed at increasing the quality of programming, would be the most radical reform seen in the country's advertising market and give commercial broadcasters access to an estimated 800 million Euros of advertising spend. The flip side is that the state sector would have to make up the ad revenue shortfall by taxing ad revenues on commercial channels and possibly levying modest taxes on internet and mobile phone users.

The risk is that if commercial channels get taxed on ad revenue they will hike prices to offset the additional tax burden. This could also reduce competition in the market as broadcast ad spots are reduced.

More from Reuters

Plea to free French journalists from death sentence

French media are putting pressure on the French government and the president of the west African country of Niger to release two journalists who are being held for visiting north Niger’s Tuareg rebels without permission. The journalists working for the Arte television channel, face the death penalty if found guilty of the charges.

Earlier this week Le Monde published an open letter appealing to Niger’s president to free reporter Thomas Dandois and his cameraman Pierre Creisson and Liberation has added its weight by publishing a piece criticising the government for not doing more to secure the release of the two men.

Fresh reports also suggest that UK Foreign Secretary, David Milliband is also being lobbied on behalf of Dandois who holds a British passport and has relatives in Scotland.

More HERE

9.1.08

PCC censures OK! for privacy breach



While OK! is busy suing Heat for infringing its copyright, it has fallen foul of the PCC code on privacy after identifying a woman (not unknown to the public) as having attended Alcoholics Anonymous with her male friend. Clause 3 of the PCC code sets out what editors should observe in relation to privacy and speculation based around pictures that invade the private sphere by discussing inherently private matters such as addiction and treatment for it.

The PCC was not impressed by OK!'s excuses - read full adjudication HERE and upheld the complaint.

Pictures and stories relating to celebrities and others attending alcoholics anonymous have been subject to extensive scrutiny and a less than satisfactory final judgment - in the case of Naomi Campbell and the Mirror. In short, you can expose someone as lying or deceiving the public but you can't intrude on or discuss the afflictions they may have without attracting complaint about privacy invasion - except if you're dealing with Britney Spears where the behaviours, afflictions and attendant coverage are already way off any self-regulatory scale.

More on Campbell v Mirror HERE and House of Lords judgment HERE

OK! sues Heat over pregnant Britney sister exclusive



OK! is suing rival celebrity magazine Heat for copyright infringement over an interview with Britney Spears' pregnant sister, Jamie Lynn Spears.

OK! had secured an 'exclusive' interview with Britney Spears' sister in which the 16 year old revealed she was pregnant - particularly topical given the media coverage about parenting in the wider Spears family. This propelled sales of OK! in the US towards the 2 million mark in the run up to Christmas.

Heat magazine had 'borrowed' - or 'quoted extensively' from OK!'s exclusive to the extent that OK! considers this to exceed any fair use and amount to blatant copyright infringement.

OK! is no stranger to litigation and the courtroom having seen off yet another celebrity magazine, Hello, in an epic court battle pegged on the rights to exclusive photographs of Michael Douglas and Catherine Zeta Jones' wedding. In that case OK! piggy-backed what was essentially a commercial damages claim for loss to sales through Hello's spoiler on the Douglas' privacy and confidentiality in their agreement with OK! over the exploitation of their wedding pictures.

A magazine - and in this case its publisher, Richard Desmond's Northern & Shell company - that will go the distance through the courts to protect its commercial interests (as it did in its litigation with Hello) is not going to let this 'extensive' borrowing from its exclusive pass unnoticed or uncompensated in the ever competitive celebrity magazine market.

So what's wrong with Heat quoting a bit from the OK! interview? This depends on how the parties and the court will interpret the context and 1988 Copyright Designs and Patents Act. Yes, one can make fair use of some attributed material but when one republishes a substantial or significant part of an original work - be that narrative, opinion or, as in this case, interview - then that can amount to infringement. In a commercial setting you can't just reproduce large sections of an interview from another magazine - even if you attribute it - if the effect is that you are basing your story substantially on the content from another source. This is particularly contentious when dealing with an 'exclusive' interview where the exclusivity (where genuine) means that the information is not readily available for the public or wider media to report on. It is the publisher that secures the 'exclusive' that at the same time buys itself commercial control over the copy it produces from such an interview.

Given OK!s track record it would be a brave and deep-pocketed Heat magazine that seeks to fight this one out in court. A settlement that compensates for the overzealous 'borrowing' seems most likely.

Heat magazine is still on the reputational back foot for the distasteful stickers it gave away towards the end of last year. It would do best to cut its reputational and financial losses and secure a few exclusives of its own.

8.1.08

McCann watch - Cuddle Cat holds the key



As we move into 2008 there is still no sign that Madeleine McCann will be found or that the investigations of either the Portuguese police or detective agency Metodo 3 have got any closer to solving the mystery surrounding Madeleine's disappearance.

To the extent there have been no tangible results, the media has kept the story alive through the steady flow of new angles, gossip and misinformation that still makes its way onto tabloid front pages, websites and broadcast bulletins.

The latest 'news' highlights the bipolarity of the coverage:
On the one hand there is the investigation and reports today that the Portuguese police wish to reinterview the Tapas 9 - the friends with whom the McCann's dined on the night Madeleine disappeared. As Mediabeak reported last month, the 'Tapas 9' recently had a reunion so will at least be prepared for another round of questioning.
On the other, the 'story' and confirmed reports that representatives of the McCanns have met with an entertainment company to discuss a potential film about Madeleine.

In absence of any breakthrough and given the difficulties in obtaining any sensible information other than 'leaks from official sources' to the Portuguese media, the story has grown very long legs of its own. The story is the news and the protagonists and story-tellers have long eclipsed Madeleine as the focus of 'news'. This poses an awkward dilemma for the McCanns who have done all they thought they could and all they thought was right to find Madeleine - or at least highlight the fact she still needs to be found - but in doing so turned the focus on themselves and ignited a media monster that is proving as difficult to tame as it is enduring.

The irony in this tragic case is that laws that were meant to protect and assist the investigation have actually forced public perception and media reporting to follow lines of inquiry that are increasingly speculative, founded on scant availability of facts and are likely to be far more prejudicial than offering sensible updates on the investigation might have been.

The one key witness which holds the secret to what happened to Madeleine and who fresh reports claim the police are keen to reinterview - is Cuddle Cat - the toy Madeleine clutched and had in bed with her when she was presumably taken - the toy Kate McCann has clutched onto as tightly as she does the hope that Madeleine will be found. Only Cuddle Cat knows what happened - why would and abductor leave behind the cuddly toy that gives their victim comfort and if they awoke might prevent them from crying? Cuddle Cat holds the key but cannot talk and any traces of stray DNA will have long been messed up.

It is to be hoped that a miracle or the bullish bragging of Metodo 3 that they will find Madeleine does provide an answer soon. Without a breakthrough the quality of media coverage is likely to become as strained as the pegs upon which it can be hooked.

ASBO reporting restrictions - ruling highlights misconceived and misconstrued system

A journalist has been refused information on ASBO recipients after the Information Tribunal ruled that Camden Council does not need to supply information about the recipients of ASBOs. As the Press Gazette reports today, Guardian journalist David Leigh had requested information about the ASBOs it had issued in 2006 from the council but been refused. The Information Commissioner subsequently overruled the council's decision last February but his ruling has now been overturned by the Tribunal. [RULING HERE]

In upholding the Council's decision to refuse the information, the Tribunal adjudicated that the Freedom of Information Act did not require the Council to release the information and cited the 1998 Data Protection Act as justification for protecting the identities of the individuals. Leigh has decided not to take his quest further - not least because the whole appeal process takes too long - but the case highlights the grossly unsatisfactory state of affairs when it comes to clarity in the rules and their application when it comes to reporting ASBOs.

Rules relating to the reporting of ASBOs (Anti Social Behaviour Orders) have caused confusion since the orders were first introduced. Much of this stems from the fact that they are civil orders issued by a council to deter antisocial behaviour and do not therefore have criminal effect or fall under the normal reporting restrictions and rules for criminal cases. In making an ASBO, it is discretionary for a council to name those who are subject to it. This seems at odds with the idea that the point of these orders is to stamp down on antisocial behaviour in communities and 'name & shame' those who engage in such behaviour. The Sun newspaper ran its own 'Shop a Yob' campaign along these lines. What this latest ruling seems to imply is that the ASBOs are there for the state - in the form of councils - to use but that when it comes to letting the press or public know who's subject to an order they can hide behind data protection law.

This is nonsense - Soham murderer Ian Huntley had remained under the radar of police in the time before his heinous crime partly because of such a flawed interpretation of what the Data Protection Act requires. If you are going to subject people to orders relating to how they behave in their community then that community and the media who report on it have a right to transparency and to know who is deemed antisocial. Just as people have a right to know if they have a paedophile living on their street or their estate, they have a right to know what other malfeasants inhabit their community. The Data Protection Act is there to protect sensitive, personal information - bank accounts, medical records and such like, however its being extended to cover any information, the release of which could be to the detriment of the subject. The argument surely is that if someone has engaged in antisocial behaviour then they should be subject to scrutiny.

Reporting restrictions become even more ridiculous when one is dealing with juveniles (those under 18). Even if they have previously been identified as subject to and ASBO, where a juvenile disobeys their ASBO and ends up in front of the magistrates courts on criminal charges, the court has the power (under the Children and Young Persons Act) to restrict the identification of the subject of the ASBO. So you end up with a situation whereby someone who continues with antisocial behaviour and goes on to commit an offence is then entitled to anonymity. The courts have in the past also ruled that magistrates should exercise caution when identifying juveniles and that they should not allow them to be identified as part of their punishment.

Its time there were some more sensible rules around the reporting of ASBOs to prevent such situations arising in the future. Its also time to revisit the Data Protection Act and its application to clarify its interpretation so that a better balance can be struck under human rights laws between freedom of information and the rights of individuals to keep sensitive information about themselves private.

Sneaky Chef sues Seinfeld



Book wars - Sneaky Chef claims Deceptively Delicious cookbook is deceptive.

The author of a best-selling, healthy-eating cookbook for kids is suing Jessica and Jerry Seinfeld for copyright and trademark infringement as well as defamation for what she claims is a blatant copy of her original book "The Sneaky Chef: Simple Strategies for Hiding Healthy Foods in Kids Favorite Meals".

Missy Chase Lapine, America's answer to Jamie Oliver, is a campaigner for improving kids eating habits and her book quickly hit the best sellers lists following its release in April 2007. Some six month's later Jessica Seinfeld published her book "Deceptively Delicious: Simple Secrets to Getting Your Kids Eating Good Food." Although the publishers had been alerted to the similarities between the two books they went ahead with publication, only making some minor amendments. Lapine's lawsuit claims that in addition to striking similarities to the overall look and feel of the book, there are also several examples of identical language.

The defamation action that has been attached to the copyright and trademark infringement claims relates to Jerry Seinfeld who, it is claimed, went on a campaign to discredit Lapine, calling her a 'nut job' and publicly calling her a 'wacko' on the David Letterman show.

More from Reuters/PRNewswire
Missy Lapine's Sneaky Chef site
Jessica Seinfeld's book and webpages

Costume designer sues Riverdance



Abhann Productions, the company behind the globally successful Riverdance show, is being sued over allegedly unpaid royalty fees due to the designer who produced the show's original costumes. Jen Kelly, one of Ireland's top haute couture designers, is suing the production company for royalty payments dating back to 2000 when a previous agreement with him expired. He claims that many of the 300 or so costumes he designed for the original show are still being used in original or modified form in the current productions and as such he is entitled to royalty payments in respect of such use.

Design Rights under the 1988 Copyright Designs and Patents Act arise automatically and don't require formal registration. While unregistered protection as a UK design right lasts for 15 years from creation, if one registers the design right then up to 25 years protection will apply.

It is not understood whether Kelly has quantified his claim and a preliminary hearing is expected later this month.

More on Design Rights HERE and HERE
More on the legal action from The Stage

7.1.08

Tom Cruise set to sue over Andrew Morton book




Tom Cruise is no stranger to scientology. Andrew Morton's books are equally likely to cause controversy. However the suggestions Morton puts forward in 'Tom Cruise: An Unauthorised Biography' have upset Cruise, who it claims was the No.2 in Scientology, to the extent that he is reported to be suing Morton's publishers, St Martin's Press for some $50m.

Morton has produced books on Diana, Monika Lewinsky and Posh & Becks but this latest compilation has been derided for having been penned without reference to any of the relevant protagonists and inventing facts. If true, this seems unlikely to deter publishers from releasing it in the US on January 15th but it may not make its way into bookshops in the UK so soon as English libel law places a more onerous test on publishers than does US law. If released in the UK publishers would have to prove that what has been written is true, while in the US the emphasis is more on the defamatory effect than the veracity of that which is printed.

So we may have to wait to read about Morton's speculation that Cruise was trying to recruit Posh and Becks to scientology (though a fly-on-the-wall documentary about the attempts to convert them would make for great reality tv). When it comes to defending their 'belief' or what many would term as 'cult', scientologists are quick to retaliate and litigate. The most celebrated recent investigation into scientology made the headlines in the UK after investigative journalist John Sweeney 'lost it' and gave them a taste of their own 'mind control' methods.

So, having witnessed what can happen when one asks a question too many, Morton and his publishers will need to work out if the potential legal action will be worth the profits from publication.

More on the content of the Morton book from the Daily Mail

Major gaffe on Parade as US magazine keeps Benazir Bhutto alive on its front page.



The editorial department at US magazine Parade must have been on a long vacation over the new year as the brutal assasination of Benazir Bhutto seems to have eluded them and allowed the slain former leader's picture and caption "I am what the terrorists fear most" to remain on the magazine's front page as it spread its way across the US in the form of a free insert into several million of the country's leading papers.

Publishers argued that with over 30 million magazines already printed it would have been logistically and economically unviable to withdraw or amend circulation. Yes the interview is interesting - more so if she were still alive - and it is arguably one of the last interviews before she died but to release a front page that totally overlooked the fact that the terrorists had in fact been her final nightmare is not the sort of commercial decision that can or should override journalistic accuracy or integrity. Credit to Parade for the interview. Discredit for failing to acknowledge she had died at the hands of the terrorists who, as she claimed, saw her as a nemesis.

Censorship: Chinese journalists told what not to write

The BBC reports on the extent of censorship in China. While most journalists around the world log onto their computer or internet connection in search of material to report on, their counterparts in China are plagued by the 'anti-pop-up' - not ads for usesless gizmos or services but directions from the state authorities on what they should or should not report on. So from manipulating Google, clamping down on YouTube and monitoring web traffic, the Chinese authorities have probably got more police in cyberspace than they have on the streets - very Second Life.

More from the BBC

3.1.08

PCC slams Sunday Mail for 'bad practice' over 'Captain Conman' story



The Press Complaints Commission has this week upheld a complaint against the Sunday Mail for what it termed "a serious matter" and "rare example of bad practice".

The complaint relates to Clause 1 of the PCC Code and the accuracy of the paper's
story "Ship of fools" about 'Captain Conman' Alex Lothian. The Scottish paper ran a story on 14th October 2007 about Mr Lothian who it said was helping the owners of the HMS Bounty (which featured in the 1962 film 'Mutiny on the Bounty')tour the boat round Europe.

The essence of the piece linked into an article that had appeared in the same paper back in 2003 that claimed Lothian was a conman and questioned his naval credentials.

Mr Lothian had complained to the PCC about the earlier piece and while there was no admission of wrong, there had been an undertaking to add a file note to ensure that any future reference to Lothian or the story acknowledged that the facts complained of were 'disputed'.

This was seemingly ignored and the Sunday Mail referred to his "Walter Mitty" claims that were "first exposed by the Sunday Mail in 2003" that alleged he "once tricked the charity Maritime Volunteer Service, claiming to be a recently-retired Navy officer embarking on a plan to form a coastal patrol called Dads Navy." It also referred to a 1995 conviction.

Mr Lothian had complained that the article was in breach of the PCC code for being inaccurate in that it failed to take into account the facts that had previously been disputed.

The PCC upheld his complaint and was particularly critical over the issue of repeating allegations without acknowledging these had been disputed and denied:
"Despite the newspaper’s contention that the allegations were true, the Commission concluded that by omitting the complainant’s position on the matter – contrary to the undertaking – the article was misleading. The Commission regarded the failure to adhere to an offer made during the course of a previous PCC investigation as a serious matter and a rare example of bad practice."