16.1.08

BBC Newsnight faces gag over Diana inquest debate



Pressure is being put on BBC's Newsnight programme not to broadcast its debate on whether the ongoing Diana inquest is a complete waste of time. The issue is currently being debated on their website and is due to be aired as part of the programme tonight. As Times online reports, Lord Justice Scott Baker's office is understood to have contacted Baroness Scotland, the Attorney General airing their fears that the programme could potentially prejudice the inquest.

In absence of an injunction the Attorney General might not have the legal authority to prevent the programme but could put pressure on the BBC to pull the segment.

As an official inquest it is still subject to the laws of contempt and if the programme could be deemed to pose a realistic and serious threat insofar as it would undermine the credibility of the Coroner's Court and any verdict it delivers then that could arguably give grounds for an injunction BUT the counter argument here would be that the debate Newsnight is airing merely reflects public sentiment and as such would not be capable of undermining the inquest.

The other option would be to construct the debate around the wider context of whether more than 10 years on we should still be digging up the past. If one avoided specific reference to aspects or credibility of the inquiry then one could argue that it would not be contemptuous as it is merely a discussion of public affairs - an exception under contempt law.

All will be revealed when the programme airs later tonight.

PCC: Press complaints reach all time high



A McCann related piece that critical of the Portuguese and a tasteless sticker in Heat magazine drove complaints about the press to record levels in 2007. Figures released by the Press Complaints Commission (PCC)this week reveal a 31% increase in complaints over 2006 to 4340 for 2007. As the two biggest offenders, Heat's tasteless sticker accounted for 143 complaints while Tony Parson's critique of Portuguese - specifically their police - in the Mirror attracted 485 complaints.

As in previous years, the increase can in part be attributed to a more visible, accessible and efficient process for making complaints. Mediabeak would also suggest that it points towards the increasing trend of interactivity between the public and its press. Technology has given the public the tools to be more engaged, interact with and report on the reporters of news. How news comes to air or appears online has been demystified and to the extent there are more news outlets and opportunities for the public to peruse, they have become more critical as consumers.

Another factor that needs to be taken into account with these figures is the fact that the PCC's remit has also been extended to cover the online environment. What would have been useful is a breakdown of how many of the complaints related to online stories as opposed to print ones. Year on year it could turn out that one is not comparing like with like.

Mediabeak has raised this with the PCC and hopes for a response ahead of waiting for the full annual report being provided.

PCC Chairman Sir Christopher Meyer commented:
“These figures reflect three things: the PCC’s greater visibility from a permanent campaign to publicise its services throughout the UK; the extension of the Commission’s remit to cover more information than ever before, including video material on the websites of newspapers and magazines; and growing confidence among the public in what the Commission has to offer. This now ranges from confidential settlements, through published c or rections and apologies, to formal rulings against newspapers and magazines, many of which took forward our case law on the vexed question of where to set the boundary between private life and information that is legitimately in the public interest.

Beyond this, we placed an increased emphasis in 2007 on sorting out problems before publication, which could otherwise have led to a formal complaint. This included in particular deploying our anti-harassment service and dispersing media scrums.”

Politics prevails over process: Secrecy order imposed on murder trial

As mediabeak reported yesterday, a secrecy order was being sought over a murder trial on the grounds of 'national security'. The media and the defendant had contested the order arguing that a right to a fair trial and a free press should prevail over state-infused intervention but Mr Justice Ousley has ruled that parts of the trial are to be held in secret. The difficulty for the media with such gags is that the basis for their order derives from material or information that is itself classified secret and so can not be placed under scrutiny. So where the state persuades a judge that the material is top secret and/or as in this case, would lead to the collapse of the trial were secrecy not to be granted then the judge is the sole arbiter.

More from
Times
Guardian

15.1.08

UK murder trial tests open justice: will it prevail over political attempts to secure a secret trial

The impartiality of the judiciary and its ability to safeguard the fundamental cornerstones of democracy in the form of open justice and press freedom is being put to the test this week in the run up to a murder trial.

UK media heavyweights are challenging a request by Home Secretary Jacqui Smith to have the trial heard 'in camera' behind closed doors under the spurious pretext that it is in the interests of national security so to do. As Mediabeak previously reported the trial, due to start on the 23rd of January, concerns the murder of an author, Allan Chappelow in June 2006. A 45 year old financial trader, Wang Yam is on trial for murder. As part of his defence, Yam had handed over a list of people who he contends are the true and likely suspect in the murder case. It is this list the Home Secretary is seeking to gag.

Here we have the unusual scenario whereby the person accused wants the press to hear what's being said and presented in court, the media want to report what the court is being presented with but the state wishes to suppress the evidence for fear of implicating its own or 'compromising national security'. It is a fundamental tenet of justice that such a case be in the open. The defendant has a right to defend himself with evidence and the media have a right to report on this as well as the evidence led by the prosecution.

Why was an 86 year old recluse murdered and who wants to cover it up?

Frances Gibb from The Times tried to answer this in a previous article.

It is to be hoped that justice will prevail and that Mr Justice Ousley who has the task of deciding will give suitable weight to the Human Rights Act and underlying European Convention principles. If not, it is a slippery slope for open justice and the media's ability to report on it.

More from:
Guardian
The Times
The Telegraph

Bing Bong Bosh - where's the News at Ten



As the battle to decide which is the greatest news programme of them all hots up, ITV is upping the stakes by banishing the ad break from its relaunched 10pm news programme. Having lost the ‘opening night’ ratings war to the BBC it appears ITV execs are fighting back. While they claim it is a commercial decision – and an expensive one at that - it does seem to be a bit of a coincidence that they choose to announce this the day after the programme relaunches – surely it would make sense to have launched it in ad free format.

Both programmes have been accused of being ‘light’ on news for their head-to-head debut but that’s perhaps a bit cynical. We have to remember that with 24 hour news on the net and tv, these flagship programmes are as much about entertainment as they are about delivering anything substantially new. That having been said, they do offer an opportunity to move their journalism from soundbites to background and insight pieces offering more or a wrap-up of news events and analysis. Hopefully this is the direction they’ll take, using their access to interview ‘exclusives’, technical capabilities (ITV’s live link from under a glacier was impressive even if not cutting edge news), graphics capabilities to enhance coverage rather than substitute for substance.

Read all about it:
First night defeat HERE
News hasn't moved on HERE
Clash of the ten o'clock titans HERE

Abramovitch sues The Sun over suggestion he’d dined on Mourinho’s head



As previously reported on Mediabeak, Roman Abramovitch is heading for the high court this month where he is suing The Sun for suggesting he had acted in an unprofessional manner in commenting on former Chelsea manager Jose Mourinho. Headlining its story in a way that only The Sun or Star can, it had a picture of Abramovitch brandishing a knife and fork about to tuck into a plate on which was superimposed the head of Mourinho along with the caption “Rom: I ate Jose! Jibe by Chelsea boss”. Abramovitch failed to see the funny side to the suggestion that he had downplayed Mourinho’s contribution to the club and proceeded to issue a writ.

The Sun may wish to check in with colleagues at The Times who defended a libel action over comments about Southampton FC Chairman Rupert Lowe. That case centred on the less graphic comment that Southampton boss Rupert Lowe had behaved ‘shabbily’ over the depature of the club's manager. It saw the jury award a staggering £250,000 in libel damages - this was subsequently reduced to £50,000.

Journalists hospitalised after TV station holds staff captive in dismissal dispute



Buenos Aires TV station Canal 9 has outraged human rights groups after it held five of its staff captive for 60 hours without allowing them access to water or toilets and turning off air conditioning and power. A dispute erupted after six colleagues were dismissed by the broadcaster. The journalists, all employees of Canal 9, had initially been prevented from entering their workplace but having managed to get in, management order the unlawful detention that resulted in two people being rushed to hospital.

This example of how not to resolve employment disputes is at odds with Argentina’s Labour Laws and a flagrant abuse of human rights.

More from RSF

Somalia ranked second most dangerous place for journalists after Iraq


Reporters Sans Frontiers has called on Somalia to end its abuse of press freedom and violation of journalists’ rights. With eight journalists having been killed in 2007, Somalia ranks as the second most dangerous country for journalists to operate in after Iraq.

RSF points to a complete lack of protection for journalists, especially in relation to security forces who make a habit of arresting and detaining them. One journalist remains in a critical condition after being shot in the face when gunmen stormed a radio station last week.

More from RSF

14.1.08

Bulletin board posters beware: comment is free – but not from defamation laws.

There have been numerous internet libel cases – notably the libel action by childless doyenne of childrearing, Gina Ford against the website by and for mothers – mumsnet.com – over comments posted about her on its discussion boards. One might be lured into a false sense of security that one is able to comment, vent ones opinions and even anger in cyberspace without comeback – not so. Defamation laws, while aged and less than satisfactory, do extend to cyberspace any ‘derogatory’ comments ‘published’. Just because a comment is on a message board for a seemingly closed community on a particular website does not mean its reach and potential effect should be underestimated.

Defamation law is engaged by the act of publication and the fact that the material published has the potential to lower the person being referred to in the ‘estimation of right thinking people generally’. So if someone’s reputation has the potential to be lessened as a result of what’s published they have the makings of a defamation action.

As the Telegraph reports this week, those contributing to financial bulletin boards may think they are debating what to long and short in the city but in doing so they are exposing themselves to litigation and a series of cases are winging their way to court to prove the point.

As Mediabeak knows from time spent at the coalface of broadcast journalism compliance, a seemingly innocuous statement that, for example, the lack of strategic focus (of X company) seems to be affecting the share price, can within minutes attract an enraged phone call from the company’s head office demanding an explanation.

So as libel law stands – unless you are satisfied that you can prove that what you have said, asserted, suggested or alluded to is true, you could be looking at a big bill for any comment you can’t prove to be true – or at least based on facts that are substantially true (thereby possibly availing yourself of a ‘fair comment’ defence).

Nuts sued: lapdancer says magazine faked interview about 'down and dirty' sex romp with Dannii Minogue








Lads mag Nuts is being sued for falsely attributing interview quotes to a lap dancer who had been caught on cctv in what the tabloids headlined as a 'lesbian sex romp' with Dannii Minogue.










The News of the World had first exposed its 'exclusive' story of how Dannii had been dirty 'dannii-ing' with Janine Marshall, who was at the time a lap dancer at London's Puss In Boots club. Marshall known as 'Jupiter' had given an interview to the paper and expressed her regret that her mum found out about her career through the press. She had not however given any interview to Nuts magazine which proceeded to patch one together headlined "Dannii Minogue played with my boobs", drawing largely on extracts from the News of the World story. The magazine even put the 'intetview' into first person and allegedly invented quotes. As the Press Gazette reports today, Marshall is now suing Nuts for false attribution and making the interview up.

Dannii Minogue has previously litigated over the story, eventually securing copyright over the leaked cctv pictures. That didn't help her much as the pictures still found their way onto the internet.

Marshall's, like Minogue's legal (as opposed to lap) action is based on the moral right of ownership in relation to copyright. Under the 1988 Copyright Designs and Patents Act (CDPA), copyright falls into 'ownership' in the commercial sense - in this case Nuts is accused of lifting quotes and text from the News of the World so it would be the paper as commercial owner of that copyright who might have a right of action - BUT the author of a copyright work (such as a documented interview or a published statement) retains what is termed the'moral' right of ownership in the work. That right includes the right not to have comment falsely attributed to oneself or derogatory treatment of the work. It will be interesting to see (1) if this gets to court without settling ans (2) if it gets to court what level of damages a court would deem appropriate in these circumstances.

s84 CDPA - False Attribution

Another case involving cctv footage stolen from nightclub

13.1.08

McCann Watch: Maddy for hire - little legal protection to prevent this perversion



There's no let up in the McCann coverage which as Mediabeak reported last week continues to track the search for fact and the continued versions of the fiction. With nothing tangible coming from the continued police investigation the McCann's want to seize the initiative and challenge police to either charge or clear them from their 'arguido' suspect status. Given that Madeleine remains unfound and her disappearance unexplained, Kate and Gerry McCann want the Portuguese police to give them some respite from their pain by releasing them from the suspect status. All the police have to hang on to - beyond their maligned secrecy laws - are the McCanns themseleves as suspects and the seemingly enigmatic persona that is Robert Murat.

Meanwhile, this week's media coverage has moved on from speculation about a possible movie deal - which the McCanns strenusously deny - to the sick parasitic people that are peddling a 'Maddy Lookalike' for a reported £600 per outing.

As Sky News and other media report, the Juliet Adams Model Agency is offering a Madeleine lookalike for hire and also hopes that they can sell her in to any movie company that makes a film about Madeleine. The agency has defended its actions as have the parents of three year old Kelsey Lynn Kudla, who - according to The Sun - say they merely want to help. How altruistic of them. They as the agency have come under fire for their tasteless attempt to expoit the situation.

While distasteful it is not necessarily illegal. This begs the question what can Madeleine (in absentia) and or her parents do on her behalf to prevent others using her image and story for commercial gain? Ones image is a personal private right and the use of it or representation of it is covered by privacy laws and also intellectual property laws such as copyright or 'passing off' under trademark law. However these laws are phrased around invading someones privacy or misappropriating their original work or image but do not provide for a situation such as this where a lookalike child may be used as a 'stand in' for Madeleine McCann. Beyond a crime reconstruction or movie its difficult to envisage when such a 'stand in' would be used but if the stand in is being freely provided and then used to depict a story that is in the public domain, it is difficult to construct that as an invasion of privacy or misappropriation of image.

So, sick and opportunistic as it may seem its not illegal. Despite her parents protestations, it is ultimately Kelsey Lynn Kudla who is being exploited as much as the situation and some may say this is in itself another form of abuse of a three year old who can hardly consent to the context she is being used in.

Cecilia Sarkozy fails to ban book and criticisms of 'President Bling Bling'



The former wife of French President Nicolas Sarkozy has failed to persuade a Paris court to issue an order preventing publication of a book about her. Cecilia Sarkozy had wanted to prevent publication of the book bearing her name by author Anna Bitton on the grounds that it contained unflattering remarks about her former husband that she claims were wrongly attributed to her or taken out of context.

The book is one of several that examine the woman who was behind the French presidential candidate, now president and discuss her influenc on him as well as his shortcomings behind the political spotlight. Her attempt to ban the book may be fuelled out of some residual deference to her former husband or desire to prevent unnecessary scandal - or accusation that she was (as she is entitled to) behaving like the woman scorned. The court was not however persuaded to ban the book and public interest in it, as in the president is describes, is as great as ever.

Both in polical and private life Nicolas Sarkozy doesn't seem to hang about and is moving quickly on with legislative measures as well as his new relationship and love with former Italian model, Carla Bruni. The French press have already shared their public's intrigue with the 'speedy' president - or as the front page of Liberation captioned him 'President Bling Bling'






Back in Britain, the Independent today ran a piece on the book Cecilia tried to ban

Other papers discussed whether Sarkozy might become engaged to and possibly even marry Carla Bruni before his official visit to the UK later in the year. According to the media, the Queen would welcome the move as it would spare 'one' having the awkward situation of offring two bedrooms when Sarkozy stays at Windsor Castle.



Let's big it up for bling-bling and hope he's as good for his country as he's proving to be at livening up its political media coverage.

12.1.08

Slovenia accused of media interference



The European Federation of Journalists (EFJ) - part of the International Federation of Journalists (IFJ) has accused the Slovenian Government of hiding behind its European Union Presidency and ignoring the issue of press censorship at home. 571 journalists have signed a petition calling on the Slovenian Government to refrain from engaging in censorship and its persistent attempts to exert undue influence on the freedom of the press to comment and criticise on the political process and wider issues in Slovenia.

Local journalists reacted angrily this week to publicity material compiled by state press officers that glossed over the issue and tried to present a different picture to its intended audience of international journalists and observers.

More HERE

11.1.08

Diana Inquest - Al Fayed's media man under fire for spinning



Mohamed Al Fayed's media adviser Michael Cole was given a rough ride when he appeared at the inquest into the deaths of Diana and Dodi this week. Under scrutiny were his statements to the press in the aftermath of the fatal crash in August 2007. He had tried to slice his story two ways and made a cynical complaint to the PCC about the media's coverage in the process. Mohamed Al Fayed's position was and is that Diana and Dodi were to be engaged and that she was pregnant. This was the reason they were, in his mind, the victims of a planned assasination by security services and not a tragic accident. Having been told by Al Fayed that this was the case, Cole had briefed the media that there was not a "scrap of evidence" to suggest this and went as far as complaining to the PCC when some newspapers suggested the pregnanacy theory. The Coroner, Lord Scott Baker considered this complaint to have been somewhat disingenuous.

More from Guardian Unlimited

Daily Mail pays out to pilot over misleading 'date rape' claim

The Daily Mail has been forced to pay 'substantial' damages to a British Airways pilot over allegations he was being investigated after two air stewardesses had been given a date rape drug. 50 year old Captian Tony Pollock had complained about the article headlined 'BA pilot facing inquiry over date rape drug'. The story had suggested he was being investigated for involvement in administering the drug when in actual fact his only connection was that he had been cited as not having done enough in response to the stweardesses feeling unwell in the aftermath of the incident. An internal investigation had cleared him of any failing in his duty of care towards his fellow colleagues.

Aside from his grievance with the Mail, Pollock poured scorn on the English libel system - in particular the fact that legal aid is not avaialble to those wishing to bring a defamation action when they have been harmed by the publication of untrue or misleading facts.

Pollock has a valid point and one which needs addressing. Following the historically longest and highly publicised 'McLibel' case, the European Court found that in not making legal aid available to defendants in libel actions it had failed in its obligations under human rights legislation - judgment details HERE Press report HERE. This has been addressed but not in the coherent and satisfactory manner that is required, or the European Court may have intended. As the law stands if one is accused of libel then, subject to qualifying for the criteria and means test one can apply for legal aid to defend a libel action BUT where one is the person defamed one cannot correspondingly apply for legal aid to bring an action. This is wrong and absurd and the law will need to be reviewed and addressed to remedy this situation. To the extent that human rights law demands that ones should be able to defend oneself fairly in a court of law, it must logically provide for the corresponding right to bring and action.